By Walt Garlington, an Orthodox Christian living in Dixieland. His writings have appeared on several websites, and he maintains his own site, Confiteri: A Southern Perspective.
Frustration with the current economic and political system in the United States continues to mount. The outburst against the Republicans across the spectrum – local, State, and federal – in the 2026 elections is the latest evidence. Only a few were in favor of the Trump regime’s hyperfocus on an AI buildout that ignored local preferences plus wars that served Israel’s interests and sent prices for many goods soaring. But now the Leftist Democrats are going to try to implement many policies that will likewise benefit relatively few and hurt many – pro-LGBT rights, massive new federal spending programs (i.e., more debt, more inflation), etc.
Neither the Right/Republicans nor the Left/Democrats seem to offer anything that will benefit the broad swath of the middling folks in the States. In revealing the big megadonors for each party, Jose Miguel showed who directs politics in the US and who will benefit from those policies (the same wealthy oligarchical class). This is the unfortunate consequence of the classical liberalism at the heart of the American Experiment – a society of ‘free’ individuals with no strong ties between them (whether religious, familial, etc.) allows super rich oligarchs to gain control of the government apparatus and use it to the benefit of themselves and their friends.
Such being the case, it is helpful to take a look back through history in order to find good alternatives to the present discredited system.
Politically, many pre-Modern systems offer valuable ideas. Ireland in her pre-Schism, Orthodox days had such. Ireland in those days had close to 200 territorial units called tuaths, each occupied by a tribe, and each tribe was headed by chief or king. The land of the tuath belonged to all the tribesmen:
‘In general, the whole of the lands of the territory belonged to all the tribe. But there was a limited circle, including the king, the nobles, and few of the leading professional men, each of whom had private rights in a certain portion of the land—the right to use those lands for the benefit of himself and his family, but not to transfer them to any person outside the tribe.
‘The foregoing refers only to special portions of the tribal land. The greater part of the tribal land was free for the use of all the people of the tribe’ (Seumas MacManus, The Story of the Irish Race, 4th edn., Konecky & Konecky, Old Saybrook, Conn., 1921, p. 293).
One may readily see how this kind of a system would protect against sudden large transfers of property to outside corporations/plutocrats. The laws of Ireland were also excellent at protecting the lesser folk from the powerful:
‘The laws protected every one . . . . They were especially framed to protect the weak against the strong. “No person,” says the law, “shall be oppressed in his difficulty.” And the law forbade the rent-payer to give service or rent to one who would exact unjustly. The greedy oppressor had to repent and pay a fine before his céile should resume giving him either rent or service’ (pgs. 294-5).
This excellent spirit of their laws carried over into the constitution her people adopted after regaining their independence from the British Empire in the 20th century, in which limits were placed on the right to property to protect against the accumulation of it in only a few hands (Article 43):
‘The State acknowledges that man, in virtue of his rational being, has the natural right, antecedent to positive law, to the private ownership of external goods.
The State accordingly guarantees to pass no law attempting to abolish the right of private ownership or the general right to transfer, bequeath, and inherit property.
The State recognises, however, that the exercise of the rights mentioned in the foregoing provisions of this Article ought, in civil society, to be regulated by the principles of social justice.
The State, accordingly, may as occasion requires delimit by law the exercise of the said rights with a view to reconciling their exercise with the exigencies of the common good.’
Many other traditional Roman Catholics have gone farther than those 20th-century Irish and seen the shortcomings of Enlightenment republics and democracies themselves. Victor Pradera of Spain is one of them and explains how older monarchies were wisely organized. The king exercises a great deal of power, but he is limited in two important ways: first, by the spiritual authority of the Church and second by the political power of local bodies. About the latter he offers this quote from Vázquez de Mella:
‘ . . . we recognize as inferior limits forming, in a certain manner, a social sovereignty, other subordinated hierarchies of social persons or bodies. These, apart from the individual person, whose natural rights we are the first to recognize as anterior and superior to every civil law, commence with the family, are prolonged in the municipality—an aggregation of families—and continue through the association of those municipalities into districts that later become united to form the region. All these powers, with other analogous corporations and with the classes connecting them, are those which limit, counteract and serve as an ORGANIC PREVENTION and not, like those useless powers you imagine, a MECHANICAL PREVENTION, against the abuses of political sovereignty, the third term circumscribed by spiritual and social sovereignty”’ (The New State, Bernard Malley, transl., AMS Press, New York, 1974, pgs. 140-1).
These intermediate institutions as they are sometimes called are a much better guarantee against tyranny than the ability to vote for this or that politician. They offer a layer of protection that a ballot by itself cannot bestow upon an individual the way a cohesive clan, neighborhood, guild, town, etc., can.
But the greatest guarantee against rule by corrupt men and women is the Orthodox Faith. The social order built by Orthodox people – whether high-born or low-born – is very admirable. The lives of St Stephen Milutin and St John Vatatzes illustrate this. St Nikolai Velimirovich says of St Milutin:
‘A great son of the Orthodox Church, King Milutin saved the Balkans from Uniatism. At that time in history when the Byzantine emperor’s conscience was weakened, this noble and God-bearing Slavic king rose up decisively and, with God’s help, saved Orthodoxy-not only in his own land, but also in all the lands of the Balkans. He who closely examines the life of the holy King Milutin will understand why God gave him success after success in all his works throughout his life. When Milutin ascended the throne, he immediately vowed to God that he would build a church for each year that he would reign. He reigned forty-two years and built forty-two churches. Next to some of the churches – for example, in Thessalonica and Constantinople – he also built hospitals for the indigent, where the poor would receive everything free of charge. Beyond that, he especially loved to give alms to the needy from his own enormous wealth. Oftentimes, this powerful and wealthy king dressed in the clothes of a poor man, and seeing the foolish extravagance of the princess and her retinue, said: “What is this, and what is it for? We are not used to such a life.” And pointing to a Serbian princess with a distaff in her hand, he said: “Behold, this is the kind of clothing we expect our daughter-in-law to wear.”’
A Christian conscience in a king will make sure that the poor are well taken care of, and that the extravagance and privileges of the rich are limited. The life of St John offers confirmation (as could the lives of many other Orthodox kings):
‘The Christ-loving Emperor John had as his homeland the great city of Adrianople, whose ancestors were leaders of the royal senate. His grandfather Constantine, called the Vatatzes, was a military commander under Manuel Komnenos (1143–1180). When the parents of this emperor died, he inherited a great amount of wealth, which he distributed to the poor, and provided offerings to the divine temples and churches. He then went to Nymphaeum in Bithynia, where at that time the palace and seat of the emperor of Constantinople was located. There he found his paternal uncle, a clergyman of the priesthood, near Emperor Theodore Laskaris (1204–1221). Through his uncle, he became friends with the emperor. He was not full of pride due to this friendship however, but he always presented himself before others with humility. Wherefore he was loved by all, having a revered disposition, being sensible in life, and possessing a gladsome expression in his eyes. He was easily approachable to everyone, mild, guileless, calm, conversant with everyone, with a gentle face. Having these virtues, he received as his wife the daughter of the emperor, whose name was Irene, after he fought against the Latin Coradus, who boasted in his strength. Having defeated him, he said: “Lord Jesus Christ help me.”
‘After his father-in-law Emperor Theodore died, the gracious John came to rule as emperor in 1222. He therefore became a fervent protector of all those who were unjustly treated, showing measure in justice. He also came to be known to all as a source of mercy, which is why he came to be called “Merciful.”’
The two-party system in the United States is not likely to bring about much good for the plain folks living here, as those political parties are mainly tools designed to serve the oligarchs who control them. The goals folks ought to be aiming for are not rule by this or that party, but rather the re-establishment of local bodies that can protect and aid individual people while also helping them develop into the full stature of a human being, which necessarily entails a preeminent role for the Orthodox Church, whose Head is Christ, Who is Perfect Man and Perfect God; and also the re-establishment of hereditary Christian rulers, who function more like fathers who love (i.e., kings) rather than narcissists who rapaciously plunder (i.e., elected officials). It is worth pondering long and hard why there are so many kings and queens and other royalty who have become holy saints and so few elected officials who have achieved theosis (are there any?).
Should we ignore elections in the States altogether, then? No, we should use them to achieve whatever good ends that we can, but with the realization that there are better ways of governing than the system we currently have. May God help us to wisely implement them once again.
Sources:
https://josemiguel1492.substack.com/p/the-democrat-oligarch-megadonors
https://josemiguel1492.substack.com/p/the-oligarchs-at-play-republican
https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/cons/en/html#article43
https://www.johnsanidopoulos.com/2010/10/saint-stephen-was-younger-son-of-king.html
https://www.johnsanidopoulos.com/2016/11/synaxarion-of-holy-emperor-john.html



